Running an import business comes with no shortage of regulatory hurdles. From classification disputes to penalty and seizure notices, customs compliance issues can disrupt operations, result in property loss, and drain resources quickly.
A customs attorney is your first line of defense when U.S. Customs and Border Protection (CBP) comes calling. Their job is to protect your interests, steer you through high-stakes disputes, and help you craft responses that stand up to scrutiny in the customs clearance process.
Wondering when to hire a customs attorney? Here are five scenarios where experienced counsel can be the deciding factor in protecting your business and avoiding costly outcomes in international trade.
1. CBP Form 28 (Request for Information)
Receiving a CBP Form 28 means Customs wants additional details about your shipment—classification, valuation, country of origin, or other factors. This request often arrives when something in your entry raises a red flag or doesn’t align with the agency’s expectations.
CBP issues Form 28 during the entry review process, and it carries deadlines that cannot be ignored. If you don’t respond properly, or at all, Customs can assess additional duties or even issue penalties.
An attorney will help you craft a response that’s precise, well-supported, and built to withstand scrutiny, cutting off problems before they snowball. Whether you’re facing a dispute over tariff classifications, merchandise value, or gaps in your paperwork, skilled guidance keeps you one step ahead and in control of the outcome.
2. CBP Form 29 or a Bill for Additional Duties
CBP Form 29, the Notice of Action, signals that Customs plans to adjust your entries, both retroactively or prospectively. For example, they might reclassify your goods under a different tariff code or change the declared value, resulting in higher duties for past and future entries.
This notice can have a significant impact on your bottom line and international shipping operations. If you disagree with the adjustment, you have a limited window to respond or protest. If you don’t respond effectively, Customs will take action on its own.
Bringing in an attorney at this stage gives you a clear advantage. They will review Customs’ position to see if it is lawful and defensible, gather and present solid evidence, and, when necessary, file a well-argued protest to challenge reclassification or valuation.
Acting decisively here often means the difference between a manageable issue and an expensive setback that could adversely affect business operations in perpetuity.
3. CBP Form 5955A (Notice of Penalty or Liquidated Damages)
Receiving a CBP Form 5955A is serious. This notice typically alleges a violation of customs law or a breach of your surety bond obligations. Penalties and liquidated damages can run high, depending on the type of violation.
Scenarios that trigger this notice range from untimely filing of an entry summary or payment of duties, to failing to redeliver merchandise as required, to overlooking critical bonded warehouse documentation. Each of these issues can open the door to steep penalties and lasting consequences for your business.
An attorney will dig into the details, assess the strength of Customs’ claims, and build a strategy to challenge or resolve the allegations. With the right approach, it’s often possible to negotiate for reduced penalties, settlement options, or even a complete dismissal of the claim.
Moving quickly shows that you’re taking the matter seriously and can significantly reduce the risk of the penalty hardening into a final, more costly assessment.
4. Notice of Detention or Notice of Seizure
When CBP issues a Notice of Detention, your goods are held while Customs evaluates whether they comply with U.S. law. If the agency decides the merchandise violates customs statutes (such as intellectual property restrictions or import or export prohibitions), it can escalate to a Notice of Seizure.
At this point, time is of the essence. Without a clear and well-supported challenge, you could lose the merchandise entirely.
An attorney will prepare detailed petitions for release or administrative relief, backed by solid evidence and clear arguments demonstrating your compliance with customs regulations. When CBP detains or seizes your goods, the clock starts ticking—and every step must be executed correctly and quickly.
Recovering seized merchandise demands a thorough command of customs procedures, strict deadlines, and the standards CBP uses to evaluate your case. With an experienced advocate guiding the process, your business stands a much stronger chance of resolving the issue quickly and securing a favorable outcome.
5. Pre-Penalty Notice Under 19 U.S.C. 1592
A Pre-Penalty Notice under 19 U.S.C. 1592 is one of the most serious enforcement measures CBP can pursue. This statute governs customs fraud and imposes penalties for material false statements, acts, or omissions in connection with imports.
Penalties under this section can reach multiples of the actual duty loss, depending on the level of culpability: negligence, gross negligence, or fraud.
Due process requires CBP to issue a Pre-Penalty Notice before finalizing the penalty, giving you the chance to respond and present your case before the agency finalizes its penalty action.
Working with an attorney helps you build a detailed defense, clarify whether the conduct was mistaken, negligent or intentional, and protect your business from severe financial repercussions. Your counsel will analyze the government’s evidence, prepare a persuasive written response, negotiate with Customs authorities, and, if necessary, represent you in administrative proceedings.
Protect Your Business Before Problems Escalate
Whether you’re dealing with a routine Request for Information or an accusation of customs fraud, these five situations can have long-lasting effects on your business. Early CBP legal help will support you in avoiding unnecessary penalties, protecting your shipments, and maintaining your standing with U.S. Customs authorities.
If you’ve received any of these notices or suspect an issue is brewing, connect with Stein Shostak Shostak Pollack & O’Hara today. Our customs lawyers in Los Angeles are here to help you respond decisively and protect your business interests.



